Planning an Italy babymoon? After visiting the Amalfi Coast twice, I’m sharing exactly where we’d stay, what we’d book again, our favorite restaurants and beach clubs, and everything I recommend for a relaxing, unforgettable trip to Capri and the Amalfi Coast.
When deciding where to go for our babymoon with baby number two, Bridger and I narrowed it down to two options: Mallorca and the Amalfi Coast. Mallorca sounded like an adventurous road-trip-style getaway, but at 22 weeks pregnant I wanted something slower—long mornings, lunches by the water, beautiful hotels to actually enjoy, and only a couple of planned activities each day. The Amalfi Coast fit that vision perfectly.
I had been to the Amalfi Coast before and stayed at Caesar Augustus in Anacapri and Santa Caterina in Amalfi, and coming back for our babymoon gave me a new perspective: this trip was about savoring the place, not trying to see everything. Below I cover where we stayed, the restaurants and beach clubs we loved, what I’d book again, and a few things I’d change next time.
Before We Dive In…
We used credit card points for both hotels, which made splurging feel much more doable. If you’ve been saving points for a bucket-list trip, this is exactly the kind of vacation to use them on—staying somewhere you love transforms the whole experience.
We also booked private boat transfers instead of ferries. Not necessary, but for me—someone who gets seasick easily and was pregnant—it was worth every cent. It made arrivals seamless, avoided ferry crowds and luggage hassle, and let our vacation start the moment we landed.
My travel recommendation: prioritize hotel quality, and if your budget allows, consider private boat transfers. On the Amalfi Coast, the two reservations I’d book in advance are beach clubs and dinner; leave the rest flexible and slow.
Where We Stayed
Caesar Augustus: Anacapri
Caesar Augustus sits high above the water in Anacapri with dramatic views you won’t tire of. Anacapri is quieter than Capri town, and being able to escape back to a peaceful hotel after exploring felt perfect for our babymoon pace. We intentionally kept our first afternoon open to enjoy the property—changing into swimsuits, ordering pool lunch, and easing into vacation mode was one of the best choices we made.
The hotel can arrange private boat transfers from Naples, which I highly recommend if you want a stress-free arrival. Also, the hotel breakfast was one of the best hotel breakfasts I’ve had—another great reason to splurge on where you stay.
Santa Caterina: Amalfi
Santa Caterina in Amalfi is one of those hotels that feels elevated without being stuffy. The service is outstanding and the beachfront setting is hard to beat. We spent our last full day rotating between the pool, the sea, lunches by the water, and long afternoon naps. If you want to splurge on one hotel in Amalfi, put Santa Caterina at the top of your list.
Capri
We spent three nights in Capri and three nights in Amalfi. Capri has energy—beach clubs, shopping and lively restaurants—while Amalfi is slower and more restorative. Starting in Capri made sense because it’s the trickier destination to reach, and three nights in each was a comfortable balance. If you can, add an extra night in Capri or finish with a night or two in Positano.
Day One: Arriving in Capri
We arrived in Naples early, took a private boat to Capri, and checked into Caesar Augustus. The plan for the afternoon: don’t leave the hotel. Lunch by the pool, a slow unpack and a walk around the property set the tone for a relaxed week. That evening we had dinner at La Terrazza di Lucullo on the hotel property—start with drinks on the balcony and aim for a late dinner to enjoy the sunset light.
Dinner: La Terrazza di Lucullo
Great food and an unbeatable view. We were pretty exhausted from travel, but enjoyed a lovely meal and slept quickly afterward.
Day Two: La Fontelina
La Fontelina is the beach club on Capri worth fighting for. Its beach chairs book months in advance during July and August. If you can’t secure chairs, show up early and ask—sometimes they have cancellations. The crystal-clear water, Faraglioni views, and the classic Capri vibe make La Fontelina a must. If it’s full, Da Luigi ai Faraglioni next door is a great alternative.
Lunch: La Fontelina
The food lives up to the hype—simple, fresh and memorable. I still dream about the chicken Caesar and the zucchini pasta. The service and atmosphere make this my favorite lunch spot on the island.
Gelato: Buonocore Gelateria
Walking back up to Capri town from La Fontelina is a workout but worth it for a gelato at Buonocore. The homemade cones are irresistible and the gelato is a perfect post-beach treat.
Dinner: a-ma-re Capri
We timed dinner around sunset at a-ma-re Capri, a lovely spot with great views. After dinner, consider visiting Il Riccio’s dessert bar for a nightcap or dessert with a seaside view.
Day Three: Casa Tua Mare
We tried Casa Tua Mare, which had just opened. The restaurant and view are beautiful, but the beach area felt crowded and close together compared with the calm experience at La Fontelina. Lunch was fine, but next time I’d spend another full day at La Fontelina instead.
Before dinner, stop at Hotel Quisisana for pre-dinner drinks and people-watching. For dinner, Fuoco at Hotel La Palma was a highlight—rooftop dining, an exciting menu and a sunset to remember. Dress code applies after 5 p.m., so plan accordingly.
Amalfi
After three nights on Capri, we took a private boat to Amalfi. On the way we stopped for lunch at Le Sirenuse Mare in Nerano. The property is stunning but expensive for beach chairs, so we skipped paid loungers and enjoyed a swim and lunch without the chair fee. The food was one of the best meals of the trip—fresh seafood, zucchini flowers, zucchini pasta and perfect service.
Checking Into Santa Caterina
We checked into Santa Caterina, rested, and had dinner at the hotel’s casual waterfront restaurant. The setting, simple menu and excellent service made it an ideal low-key evening.
Day Five: Amalfi
Amalfi’s slower pace suited us: breakfast at the hotel, beach chairs and a long, lazy afternoon. For dinner, Da Gemma in town was a memorable meal—excellent traditional fare and warm service.
Day Six: Our Last Full Day
We saved this day to do almost nothing—lounge, swim, read, and repeat at Santa Caterina’s beach club. It felt indulgent and perfectly restful. Lunch and dinner at the hotel’s waterfront restaurant became favorites; simple pasta with olive oil, garlic and chili flakes is a must-order.
If I Were Planning This Trip Again…
Book these ASAP: La Fontelina, Fuoco by Casa Tua, Da Gemma, Caesar Augustus and Santa Caterina. Worth every penny: private boat transfers, Caesar Augustus and Santa Caterina. What I’d skip: Casa Tua Mare beach club.
Planning Tips for the Amalfi Coast
- Reserve beach clubs and dinners in advance—everything else can be flexible.
- Book La Fontelina early if you travel in peak months.
- Three nights in Capri and three nights in Amalfi felt ideal; if you can extend, add nights in Capri or end with Positano.
- Choose lunch at beach clubs and dinner in town for the best experience.
- If you can afford it, private transfers are a worthwhile splurge for comfort and convenience.
Our 6-Day Italy Babymoon: Capri & Amalfi Itinerary
Day One
Stay: Caesar Augustus
- Arrive in Naples in the morning
- Private boat transfer to Capri
- Lunch by the pool and relax at the hotel
- Dinner: La Terrazza di Lucullo
Day Two
Morning: La Fontelina Beach Club
Lunch: La Fontelina
Gelato: Buonocore Gelateria on the walk back up
Dinner: a-ma-re Capri (consider Il Riccio for dessert afterward)
Day Three
Morning: Casa Tua Mare
Lunch: Casa Tua Mare
Drinks: Hotel Quisisana
Dinner: Fuoco by Casa Tua at Hotel La Palma
Day Four
Private boat transfer to Amalfi
Lunch: Le Sirenuse Mare
Check into Santa Caterina and relax
Dinner: Santa Caterina waterfront restaurant
Day Five
Hotel and beach day
Dinner: Da Gemma in town
Day Six
Santa Caterina beach chairs, lunch by the pool, swim and read.
Day Seven
Car transfer to Naples airport early in the morning.
Other Places I’d Recommend
Beach Clubs
Da Luigi ai Faraglioni (Capri) — A great alternative if La Fontelina is fully booked; recently updated loungers and umbrellas and an easy walk to La Fontelina for lunch.
Restaurants
Zuma Capri — Modern, Japanese-inspired dining at Capri Palace for a different take on island dining.
Da Paolino (Capri) — Dining beneath lemon trees is a quintessential Capri experience worth trying once.
Aurora Capri — A longstanding local favorite known for lively atmosphere and excellent pizza.
Conca del Sogno (Nerano) — Famous for seafood and long, festive lunches if you want a boozy, lively meal by boat.
Hotels
Hotel Quisisana (Capri) — If you prefer staying in Capri town, this is a prime choice; great for pre-dinner drinks and people watching even if you don’t stay there.
Le Sirenuse (Positano) — An unforgettable splurge for service, views and an exceptional breakfast experience; great to add one or two nights if your budget allows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Capri worth staying overnight?
Yes. Day trippers often wish they had stayed longer. Overnight gives you time to enjoy the island’s slower moments.
How many nights should I spend in Capri?
Three nights felt perfect for us, but four would be even better if you have the time.
Capri or Amalfi?
Both. They offer different vibes: Capri is livelier and Amalfi slower and more restorative. If possible, split your time between the two.
Is La Fontelina worth it?
Absolutely. Book early in peak season—this beach club is iconic for a reason.
Are private boat transfers worth the money?
They’re a splurge but highly recommended for comfort, convenience and the ability to enjoy the coastline without ferry crowds.
Is the Amalfi Coast a good babymoon destination?
Yes—great food, beautiful water, and a pace that encourages relaxation make it an ideal babymoon spot.
Final Thoughts
I wouldn’t change much about this itinerary. Doing the Amalfi Coast a second time allowed me to show Bridger my favorite places while leaving room to relax and savor each day. If you’re planning a trip and have questions I didn’t answer here, feel free to ask. I hope this guide helps you plan a babymoon you’ll love.